Key Takeaways:
- Blue sky value for the average publicly owned dealership fell 10.4% to $17 million, according to the Q3 2026 Haig Report
- Dealership profits dropped 14.9% year over year in the third quarter as new, used and F&I margins all tightened
- Haig Partners raised blue sky multiples for Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Toyota while lowering them for Subaru, Mazda and Hyundai-Genesis
Dealership owners will need to keep a close eye on their bottom line heading into 2027. The Q3 2026 Haig Report, published by Haig Partners on Nov. 16, shows a franchise market that has officially flattened after years of outsized post-pandemic gains, with profits and valuations both moving lower even as deal activity holds up.
While the numbers aren’t exactly rosy, they also aren’t a sign it’s time to panic. Things have been trending this way for most of the year, and dealers should treat this as a normalization rather than a collapse. Dealership profits are still well above pre-pandemic levels, but the direction has turned, and owners weighing a sale, an acquisition, or simply a plan for 2027 need to understand what is driving the dip.
What Happened to Dealership Blue Sky Values in 2026?
Blue sky value, the premium a buyer pays above a dealership’s hard assets for its earnings potential and franchise rights, fell 10.4% to $17 million for the average publicly owned dealership over the trailing 12 months through the third quarter, according to the Q3 2026 Haig Report. That is down from $19 million in 2025, though it remains roughly double the pre-pandemic average.
The decline traces directly to earnings. Average pre-tax income per publicly owned store fell 11.4% on a trailing 12-month basis, and blue sky values move with those profits over time.
“Some of the warning lights on the dashboard are blinking yellow, but our industry is still performing pretty well,” said Alan Haig, President and Founder of Haig Partners. “Dealership profits are declining, but buyers are still willing to pay substantial premiums for the franchises they believe will perform best in the years ahead. We’re seeing a flight to quality, and the gap between brands is getting wider. A Toyota dealership can sell for more than $100 million in blue sky while an Audi dealership on the same street might command less than $5 million.”
Why Are Dealership Profits Falling Even Though Sales Are Steady?
The average publicly owned dealership generated about $900,000 in adjusted pretax income in the third quarter of 2026, down 14.9% from the same period in 2025 and the weakest third-quarter result since 2019. Trailing 12-month earnings fell 11.4% to $3.6 million, still 72.7% above 2019 levels but well below recent highs.
Margin compression is spreading across departments. Margins are shrinking, and operating expenses are a larger share of gross profit. Fixed operations grew just 0.6% through the first nine months of 2026, trailing inflation. Real estate costs are climbing too, as sale-leaseback firms now underwrite dealership properties at capitalization rates of roughly 7.5% to 8%, up from 6.5% to 7% in prior years, which translates into lower property valuations for the same rental income.
“Dealers are still earning substantially more than they did before COVID, but they’re being squeezed from both sides,” said Haig. “Consumers are dealing with higher payments and ownership costs, while dealers face tighter margins, rising expenses and slower growth in fixed operations. The dealers who manage those pressures best will have more options, whether they want to acquire additional stores, hold on to what they’ve built or eventually sell for strong blue sky values.”
Which Franchises Are Gaining Value and Which Are Losing It?
Haig Partners raised its blue sky multiple ranges for four franchises it considers best positioned for the years ahead: Lexus, now at 10.0x to 12.0x, the highest in the industry; Mercedes-Benz, at 9.0x to 10.0x; BMW, at 8.5x to 10.0x; and Toyota, at 8.0x to 10.0x. Each benefits from strong profitability, factory relationships dealers describe favorably, and product strategies aligned with customer demand.
At the same time, the firm lowered its ranges for Subaru, Mazda and Hyundai-Genesis, along with the upper end of Volkswagen’s estimated dollar value range. According to the report, three of those franchises have limited hybrid offerings and are losing market share, a disadvantage in a market in which affordability and fuel efficiency currently weigh heavily on buyer decisions.
Why are Consumers Struggling to Afford New Vehicles Right Now?
Affordability pressure sits behind much of the market’s flatness. The typical monthly new vehicle payment reached $776 in September, the highest level since December 2023, according to the Cox Automotive and Moody’s Analytics Vehicle Affordability Index. Edmunds data shows a record 21.2% of new vehicle buyers took on payments of $1,000 or more per month, while a record 25.5% of loans ran 84 months or longer.
Those pressures are changing who is buying. Cox Automotive reported that retail vehicle sales declined 5% through September while fleet sales rose 7%, suggesting payment-sensitive shoppers are delaying purchases or trading down to smaller, more affordable vehicles.
Is Dealership Acquisition Activity Still Active Despite the Slowdown?
Buy-sell activity has held up better than profits. An estimated 455 dealerships were acquired through the first nine months of 2026, down only 3.8% from 473 a year earlier, and up 5.8% when excluding Asbury Automotive Group’s 43-dealership Herb Chambers acquisition in 2025.
Private buyers accounted for 439 of those deals, up 8.7%, while publicly traded groups were net sellers as they redirected capital toward stock buybacks. Luxury dealership acquisitions rose 43.7%, and import acquisitions increased 27%, while domestic acquisitions fell 7.8%, strengthening the flight to quality Haig described.
What Should Dealership Owners Do Next?
For owners weighing a sale, an acquisition or a succession plan, understanding the full buyer market matters more than ever. As Haig put it, one buyer’s offer “doesn’t establish what a dealership is worth.” Owners of in-demand franchises are often approached directly, but a wider market check can reveal significantly larger offers.
Desirable franchises are still commanding strong premiums despite the overall decline in average values, so owners considering a sale should get an independent valuation before accepting any offer.
The full Q3 2026 Haig Report includes additional detail on individual franchise multiples, regional buy-sell trends, and a franchise highlight on Kia’s rising performance. View it at haigpartners.com/haig-report for complete data and franchise-by-franchise analysis.
Related Stories: