• DD-Square-Logo_resized
  • ATTEND LAS VEGAS
    • Attendee
      • Registration & Pricing
      • Agenda At-A-Glance
      • Exhibitor List/Floor Plan
      • Sponsor List
      • Hotel & Travel
      • Hosted Dealer Program
      • FAQ
      • Mobile App
    • Exhibitor
      • Exhibit/Sponsor
      • Advertising Opportunities
      • Exhibitor Resources
      • Exhibitor Tips
    • Education
      • Overview
      • Show Schedule
  • ABOUT
    • Conference Overview
    • Best Of Awards
    • Become a Speaker
    • Press Inquiries
    • Partnership Programs
    • Health & Safety
    • Contact Us
    • Get Updates
  • RESOURCES
    • Webinars
    • Downloads
  • NEWS
    • Auto Retail News
    • Digital Editions
    • Press Releases
    • Submit Editorial
    • Subscribe
  • .
  • ATTEND LAS VEGAS
    • Attendee
      • Registration & Pricing
      • Agenda At-A-Glance
      • Exhibitor List/Floor Plan
      • Sponsor List
      • Hotel & Travel
      • Hosted Dealer Program
      • FAQ
      • Mobile App
    • Exhibitor
      • Exhibit/Sponsor
      • Advertising Opportunities
      • Exhibitor Resources
      • Exhibitor Tips
    • Education
      • Overview
      • Show Schedule
  • RESOURCES
    • Webinars
    • Downloads
  • ABOUT
    • Conference Overview
    • Best Of Awards
    • Become a Speaker
    • Press Inquiries
    • Partnership Programs
    • Health & Safety
    • Get Updates
  • NEWS
    • AUTO RETAIL NEWS
    • PRESS RELEASES
    • DIGITAL EDITIIONS
    • SUBMIT EDITORIAL
    • SUBSCRIBE

Las Vegas: Oct 17-19, 2023

REGISTER NOW EXHIBIT / INQUIRE
Q

NEWS:

Everyone | Trending Industry News | Vendors
June 9, 2016

Overcome Loss Aversion and Make Tough Decisions

Posts:
Everyone | Trending Industry News | Vendors
June 9, 2016

Overcome Loss Aversion and Make Tough Decisions

You may not have heard of them, but Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky are rock stars. Their band name doesn’t have the same ring as say, Hall & Oates, but these men helped develop some of the most influential theories in the history of Behavioral Economics. One of their primary focuses centered around decision making; more specifically how humans can make irrational decisions based on biases and heuristics stemming from a variety of sources. As a result of his work Kahneman received the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, and one of the findings that led to that award was his work on Prospect Theory. This article will focus on one of the principle findings made within Prospect Theory called Loss Aversion and will tie the concept of Loss Aversion to the car dealer’s decision-making process related to inventory management.

Loss Aversion states that the effect of a loss is more impactful than the effect of a gain. For instance, the pleasure gained from receiving $1000 is not equal to the pain felt from losing $1000; the latter is much more impactful. Tiger Woods offers a golfing analogy that helps expound on the point: “Any time you make big par putts, I think it’s more important to make those than birdie putts,” Woods said. “You don’t ever want to drop a shot. The psychological difference between dropping a shot and making a birdie, I just think it’s bigger to make a par putt.”

Prior to jumping into the article, if you want a quick “Dummies” synopsis to reference, click here

One interesting finding in the analysis is how people, in general, are risk averse when it comes to gains and risk seeking when it comes to losses, something referred to as The Reflection Effect. Here is an example from a 1981 Kahneman and Tversky paper titled “The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice”

“Imagine that the U.S. is preparing for the outbreak of an unusual Asian disease, which is expected to kill 600 people. Two alternative programs to combat the disease have been proposed. Assume that the exact scientific estimate of the consequences of the programs are as follows:

If Program A is adopted, 200 people will be saved.

If Program B is adopted, there is 1/3 probability that 600 people will be saved, and 2/3 probability that no people will be saved.”

Which would you choose? In a sample of 152 people, 72% of respondents chose Program A. Now let’s see what happens when two new programs are introduced.

“If Program C is adopted 400 people will die.

If Program D is adopted there is 1/3 probability that nobody will die, and 2/3 probability that 600 people will die”

Now which would you choose? In a sample of 155 people, only 22% chose Program C, which is the identical outcome to Program A above! Program A = Program C and Program B = Program D in terms of expected outcomes, and simply changing the wording to emphasize gains and losses causes a complete switch of preference. We contradict ourselves based on the phrasing of the same problem.

Luckily in the automotive world we don’t have to make decisions like the one above, but in terms of inventory selection and management we fall victim to Loss Aversion. When our DRIVIN Sales and Trading teams speak to dealer partners, we hear statements like: “I can’t sell that car unless I make $X on it,” “My GM will kill me if I get rid of that VIN without making money on it,” and finally “I’ll hold that car as long as it takes to sell.” When we hear this feedback I can only help but think of Loss Aversion as the culprit, the fear of taking a hit or having a purchase decision looked at as a failure when in reality doing nothing is making the matter exponentially worse.

When dealers source inventory from auctions, trade-ins, or other available means, the emphasis is on maximizing potential profit from the transaction. Using years of experience in the industry, availability of inventory in the market, and forecasted sales and pricing data from various software tools, dealers target specific VINs that hopefully turn quickly and profitably. But in instances where the ideal scenario doesn’t come to fruition the dealer must flip the line of thinking from maximizing profit to minimizing loss.

A compounding factor is that the vehicle value is NOT static. As a vehicle sits on a dealer’s lot, depreciation takes its toll, financing charges add up, consumer behavior shifts, and the used inventory in the market adjusts. Our Analytics team has begun performing a preliminary analysis to find the probability of moving a VIN after stocking it for 90 days and, while the % changes based on market, the national average is about 18% thus far. Loss Aversion clouds better judgement of wholesaling that VIN and targeting something that has a higher propensity to sell.

This decision making framework requires dealers to answer questions such as “What happens if I sell now? What do I lose?” then compare that scenario to “What is the risk of keeping this inventory and incurring additional losses? What do I lose by passing up the opportunity to sell today?” This type of decision needs be objective as it relates to the bottom line and shift away from the biases caused by Loss Aversion. Leadership within the dealership needs to shift its focus away from reprimanding buyers and used car managers for not making money on every vehicle but rather encouraging them to make sound decisions to get out of vehicles that aren’t moving. Arming your team with the best data to stock the right vehicles for your used lot is imperative and will lead to better long term results, but the process is not perfect. Tough decisions will always be required.

When viewing aged inventory on your lot, and consulting a partner such as DRIVIN who calculates market demand and pricing data for our dealer partners, you can make more rational decisions around exiting inventory that carries both real and opportunity costs and sourcing vehicles that fit the needs of your shoppers. Not every vehicle you stock is going to sell quickly and profitability, whether it is due to a lack demand, competitive pricing or just plain bad luck. The lesson is to minimize the negative effect of this loss by getting out of that inventory before it continues to suck money from your bottom line. DRIVIN and our Optimal Lot methodology aims to provide the data and analytical insights to our dealer partners to assist with this process on both ends: targeting inventory in the market that your dealership should be stocking and finding a dealer that would want to purchase a vehicle you are willing to wholesale.

Written by John Manganaro, VP of Analytics & Pricing, DRIVIN

Everyone•Trending Industry News•Vendors

SHARE

Share on Email
Share on Linkedin
Share on Facebook
Share on Pinterest
Share on Twitter
← Previous Article Next Article →
Posts Industry Press Releases

Mopar and Petra Automotive Products Partner to Launch New Maintenance Products to Dealers Across North America

Petra Automotive Products, the fastest growing premium automotive products manufacturer in the world, is proud to announce 11 of their best-in-class products will be launched under the Mopar® brand for Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep®, Ram and FIAT® dealers
Posts Industry Press Releases

Dealer Alchemist: An Inc. 5000 Honoree for the Second Consecutive Year

Announcement from Dealer Alchemist Dealer Alchemist, a digital advertising agency specializing in the automotive industry, is proud to announce its recognition as an Inc. 5000 Honoree for the second year in a row. With an impressive ranking of No. 10
Posts Industry Press Releases

Mopar and Petra Automotive Products Partner to Launch New Maintenance Products to Dealers Across North America

Petra Automotive Products, the fastest growing premium automotive products manufacturer in the world, is proud to announce 11 of their best-in-class products will be launched under the Mopar® brand for Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep®, Ram and FIAT® dealers
Posts Industry Press Releases

Fleming Ford Joins NCM Associates to Launch Advanced Leadership Development and Executive Coaching Programs

Announcement from NCM Associates NCM Associates is thrilled to announce that Fleming Ford will be joining the organization as the Director of Talent Solutions. In this role, Fleming will take the lead in designing and implementing leadership developm
Posts Industry Press Releases

Ben Chodor Assumes Role of CEO at CallRevu, a Serent Portfolio Company

Announcement from CallRevu Experienced Tech Leader to Steer CallRevu’s Growth and Innovation CallRevu, a premier automotive communication solutions provider and a portfolio company of Serent Capital, is pleased to announce the appointment of Ben Ch
Posts Marketing & AdvertisingTrending Industry News

5 Videos Every Auto Salesperson Needs to Make

In today’s digital age, videos have become an indispensable tool for salespeople to connect with prospects and enhance their sales efforts. From personalized introductions to engaging demonstrations, leveraging the right types of videos can sig
Posts Marketing & AdvertisingTrending Industry News

From Bland to Brand: Leveraging Video Content to Catalyze Customer Connections and Drive Profit Center Growth

In the dynamic landscape of the automotive industry, where competition is fierce and consumer expectations are ever-evolving, the power of effective communication cannot be underestimated. As the digital era continues to reshape the way businesses en
Posts Dealer Ops & LeadershipTrending Industry News

What’s Needed to Truly Establish a Digital Presence for Used Auto Dealers, Lenders and OEMs

The auto industry has been laser-focused on digitizing the retail shopping experience for several years, especially since the pandemic in 2020. However, the right digital retail strategy for today’s used dealer goes beyond up leveling a dealer’s

NEWSLETTER

SUBSCRIBE

DEALER MAGAZINE

Dealer Magazine March/April 2023 Issue Featuring an Interview with NADA 2023 Chairman
MAGAZINE
Digital Dealer Logo White
FOLLOW US ON
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
© 2023 Emerald X, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
ABOUT    CAREERS    AUTHORIZED SERVICE PROVIDERS   DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION   TERMS OF USE   PRIVACY POLICY