As we come to the end of 2024, digitaldealer.com asked for the experts who contributed their knowledge to take both a look back at this year and what is ahead in 2025. This entry is from Tim Yalich, head of automotive strategy, Wolters Kluwer
The third quarter of 2024 has proven to be a pivotal period for the automotive and auto lending industries, as shown by the latest third quarter Auto Finance Digital Transformation Index. Despite a challenging sales environment, with overall industry sales declining by approximately two percent, the digital transformation in auto finance continues to gain momentum.
Affordability issues persisted, with average vehicle prices remaining significantly higher than pre-pandemic levels, although a slight 1.7 percent decrease from the previous year was observed. High interest rates further dampened demand, as the benefits from Federal Reserve rate cuts had not yet materialized in the auto loan market.
The digitization adoption rate for securitization markets continued to accelerate, with digital auto loan volume in securitization markets decreasing 10 percent compared to Q2 2024. However, this decrease was less severe than the 41percent decrease reported in the previous quarter. Over the past four years, digital adoption for securitizations has increased by an impressive 73 percent, slightly higher than the four-year trend recorded in the previous quarter (70 percent).
This sustained growth demonstrates the industry’s commitment to embracing digital solutions, even in the face of continued economic headwinds.
Annual Trends Coming Into Focus
The Auto Finance Digital Transformation Index reveals a fascinating trend in digital adoption across different quarters. While there is typically a spike in volume during the first quarter of each year, attributed to tax season and income tax returns, the overall trend shows a consistent elevation in digital adoption year over year. This “new normal” is characterized by a plateau effect following the Q1 spike, with each subsequent year establishing a higher baseline for digital execution.
This pattern indicates that once lenders transition to digital workflows, they tend to stick with them, highlighting the growing nature of digital adoption in the auto finance industry.
When examining the different segments of auto lenders, clear disparities in digital adoption emerge. Captive lenders and prime market players have largely embraced digital workflows, with most of their volume now processed digitally. However, credit unions and regional lenders lag behind in adoption rates. This discrepancy can be attributed to various factors, including limited IT resources, unique operational requirements, and challenges in finding suitable partners that can customize digital solutions to meet their specific needs.
Interestingly, despite their slower adoption rates, credit unions and regional lenders represent the areas with the most significant growth potential in digital transformation in the near future. The industry has witnessed a notable shift in recent years, with several credit union securitizations occurring in the secondary market over the past three to four years – a phenomenon previously unseen in the auto finance sector.
This development signals a growing recognition among credit unions of the value of digital workflows and their potential to expand into new market segments.
How The Economy Shaped Digitization Patterns
The impact of economic factors on digital adoption in the auto finance industry has been mixed. Surprisingly, major events such as the ransomware attack this summer did not significantly affect the digital adoption index. This resilience suggests that the industry has developed robust alternative digital execution environments, allowing affected dealers to continue operations despite system disruptions.
Similarly, the recent interest rate reductions have not yet triggered a substantial impact on the volume of financed auto sales or digital adoption rates. Industry participants appear to be taking a “wait and see” approach, anticipating further rate reductions before making significant changes to their strategies. This cautious stance underscores the complex relationship between economic factors and digital transformation in the auto finance sector.
Trump Election Affect
Looking ahead to 2025, the outlook for digital adoption in the auto finance industry remains positive. As lenders continue to invest in technology during challenging times, they are positioning themselves to quickly respond to potential market upswings. There is a growing focus on back-end workflow processing, including areas such as credit decisioning, funding automation, and the integration of AI and machine learning. Fraud prevention has also emerged as a key driver for digital adoption, with lenders recognizing that advanced digital tools are essential for implementing effective safeguards.
The U.S. election in 2024 introduces an element of uncertainty into the market, potentially influencing digital adoption trends in ways that are difficult to predict. However, we believe that the growth trajectory for digital transformation will likely continue, with another plateau expected in 2025 as the market adjusts to new realities.
One significant factor that may contribute to increased digital adoption in 2025 is the CFPB’s Section 1071 rule requiring lenders to collect and report data on each loan application, including demographic information about applicants. To comply efficiently, auto lenders will benefit from digitizing documents and back-office processes. Automating workflows will streamline data collection, tracking, and reporting, reducing manual errors and ensuring compliance. Digitization will also help standardize lending processes, facilitate compliance controls, and enable proactive monitoring of lending practices to avoid potential disparities.
In the securitization market, the Auto Finance Digital Transformation Index reveals intriguing trends. The volume of digital loans monetized through securitization platforms has remained relatively high in recent years, with 2024 on track to surpass the record-setting volumes of 2023. While there is typically a drop-off in asset volumes during the second half of the year, the overall trend points to growing trust in digital platforms within the securitization market.
The increasing digitization of loan data has had a positive impact on the valuation of securitized portfolios. As more information becomes available in digital formats, there is a higher level of trust in the platforms, leading to lower perceived risk. This trend is reinforcing the path of adoption for digitization, as stakeholders recognize the benefits of enhanced data integrity and transparency.
What To Expect In 2025
Industry projections into next year suggest a slight improvement in digital loan origination volumes compared to the current year. However, the potential for interest rate reductions introduces the possibility of increased refinancing activity, which could impact overall volumes. Additionally, the presence of financial institutions with regular securitization mechanisms may contribute to sustained high levels of activity in the coming year.
Overall, the third quarter Auto Finance Digital Transformation Index paints a picture of an industry in transition, navigating economic challenges while steadily embracing digital solutions. The resilience of digital adoption in the face of market fluctuations, coupled with the potential for growth in under-adopted segments, suggests that the digital transformation of the auto finance industry is far from complete.
The interplay between economic factors, technological advancements, and changing consumer behaviors will continue to shape the landscape of auto finance, with digital transformation remaining at the forefront of industry evolution.
Related Stories:
